Blame It On The Puritans - POSTED ON: May 21, 2011
Anne Barone's description of growing up in the 1950s mirrors my own experience, and I am very entertained by her Puritan vs. French comparison.
"Blame it on the Puritans. If you wonder why the French, the most food-obsessed people on the planet, can eat all that cream, butter, and egg yolks and struggle far less with excess weight than Americans who dutifully take home shopping bags of sugarless and fat-free, the answer is: the Puritans. The French never had any; the Americans did. The French had Joan of Arc, Napoleon Bonaparte, Charles de Gaulle, and Brigitte Bardot. But no Puritans. Back in 1620 when the Puritans stepped off the Mayflower, they brought with them the intellectual baggage that if something feels good and makes us happy, it is bad. Discomfort and sacrifice are good. The more uncomfortable and unpleasurable something is, the Puritans thought, the better for you. Of course this Puritan philosophy grew out of strong religious conviction. The French were also religious -- in their own fashion. When they wanted to give thanks to God, they built -- by hand, no less -- huge, architecturally magnificent Gothic cathedrals. The construction of Chartres, no doubt, burned more calories than all the Jane Fonda workout videos ever sold. For Thanksgiving, the American Puritans fixed a big dinner and ate it. Our annual reenactment of this feast kicks off that part of the year when the average American gains six pounds. The Puritan legacy was still strong three centuries later when I was growing up in the 1950s. In that small Bible Belt town, drinking alcohol was a sin, smoking was a sin, playing cards was sin, dancing was a sin, and going to the movies was a sin. Any effort to improve your appearance was viewed with suspicion. Once I arrived at a friend's house to find her grandmother in a rage. Pointing a damning finger, she demanded, "What do you think about a girl who would go against the will of God?" My friend, it turned out, had straightened her naturally curly hair. In that Bible Belt milieu, sex outside marriage put you on the fast track to Hell. As for sex in marriage, you weren't supposed to enjoy it. The only sanctioned pleasurable activity was eating. I have witnessed church family night dinners that were food orgies that would have shocked the un-Puritanical French right out of their socks. The French seek equal pleasure in a well-prepared meal as in a session of passionate lovemaking. Actually the French favor alternating one with the other. But everything in moderation. The French, after all, coined the phrase "la douceur de vivre, the sweetness of living". Americans coined the phrase "No pain, no gain." The way this works, you go through the pain of dieting. Then you gain it all back. THE NOUVEAUX PURITANS In recent decades American Puritanism has undergone an evolution. Activities no longer prohibited for religious or moral reasons, are now on the no-no list as unhealthy. This has given the Puritan mentality an in-road to spoiling our previously okay pleasure in eating. The rules are simple: Anything that tastes good, like grilled steak, cheese enchiladas, fresh-brewed coffee, or Key lime pie, are poisons, guaranteed to kill us. Foods such as tofu, bean sprouts, and plain low-fat yogurt are cure-alls promised to put the medical profession out of business and make us all live to 110. Most new products the food industry has put on the shelves recently carry some (mostly overhyped) health claim. And whatever the fad health food, they add it to everything. During the oat bran craze about the only products on the supermarket shelf without this gritty little addition was laundry detergent and disposable diapers. These Nouveux Puritans have studies to back up their claims. But my faith in "studies" is weak. I remember one study that concluded that wearing lipstick caused cancer. However, to ingest as much lipstick as they had pumped into those poor little research mice, a human had to eat 90 tubes of lipstick per day! Across the Atlantic the French hear the results of the American Nouveux Puritan food studies, pause a moment from eating their pate de fois gras, cut a bite of bifteck, sip their Beaujolais, and contemplate the cheese tray as they shrug and say, "Il sont fous, ces Americains. They're crazy, those Americans."
"Blame it on the Puritans. If you wonder why the French, the most food-obsessed people on the planet, can eat all that cream, butter, and egg yolks and struggle far less with excess weight than Americans who dutifully take home shopping bags of sugarless and fat-free, the answer is: the Puritans.
The French never had any; the Americans did. The French had Joan of Arc, Napoleon Bonaparte, Charles de Gaulle, and Brigitte Bardot. But no Puritans.
Back in 1620 when the Puritans stepped off the Mayflower, they brought with them the intellectual baggage that if something feels good and makes us happy, it is bad. Discomfort and sacrifice are good. The more uncomfortable and unpleasurable something is, the Puritans thought, the better for you. Of course this Puritan philosophy grew out of strong religious conviction.
The French were also religious -- in their own fashion. When they wanted to give thanks to God, they built -- by hand, no less -- huge, architecturally magnificent Gothic cathedrals. The construction of Chartres, no doubt, burned more calories than all the Jane Fonda workout videos ever sold.
For Thanksgiving, the American Puritans fixed a big dinner and ate it. Our annual reenactment of this feast kicks off that part of the year when the average American gains six pounds.
The Puritan legacy was still strong three centuries later when I was growing up in the 1950s. In that small Bible Belt town, drinking alcohol was a sin, smoking was a sin, playing cards was sin, dancing was a sin, and going to the movies was a sin. Any effort to improve your appearance was viewed with suspicion. Once I arrived at a friend's house to find her grandmother in a rage. Pointing a damning finger, she demanded, "What do you think about a girl who would go against the will of God?" My friend, it turned out, had straightened her naturally curly hair.
In that Bible Belt milieu, sex outside marriage put you on the fast track to Hell. As for sex in marriage, you weren't supposed to enjoy it. The only sanctioned pleasurable activity was eating. I have witnessed church family night dinners that were food orgies that would have shocked the un-Puritanical French right out of their socks.
The French seek equal pleasure in a well-prepared meal as in a session of passionate lovemaking. Actually the French favor alternating one with the other.
But everything in moderation. The French, after all, coined the phrase "la douceur de vivre, the sweetness of living". Americans coined the phrase "No pain, no gain." The way this works, you go through the pain of dieting. Then you gain it all back.
THE NOUVEAUX PURITANS
In recent decades American Puritanism has undergone an evolution. Activities no longer prohibited for religious or moral reasons, are now on the no-no list as unhealthy. This has given the Puritan mentality an in-road to spoiling our previously okay pleasure in eating. The rules are simple: Anything that tastes good, like grilled steak, cheese enchiladas, fresh-brewed coffee, or Key lime pie, are poisons, guaranteed to kill us. Foods such as tofu, bean sprouts, and plain low-fat yogurt are cure-alls promised to put the medical profession out of business and make us all live to 110.
Most new products the food industry has put on the shelves recently carry some (mostly overhyped) health claim. And whatever the fad health food, they add it to everything. During the oat bran craze about the only products on the supermarket shelf without this gritty little addition was laundry detergent and disposable diapers.
These Nouveux Puritans have studies to back up their claims. But my faith in "studies" is weak. I remember one study that concluded that wearing lipstick caused cancer. However, to ingest as much lipstick as they had pumped into those poor little research mice, a human had to eat 90 tubes of lipstick per day!
Across the Atlantic the French hear the results of the American Nouveux Puritan food studies, pause a moment from eating their pate de fois gras, cut a bite of bifteck, sip their Beaujolais, and contemplate the cheese tray as they shrug and say, "Il sont fous, ces Americains. They're crazy, those Americans."
I first became aware of this quote from the book Chic & Sllm (2001) by Anne Barone several years ago when it was posted by wones, who is active in the No S Diet forum, and is also registered here at DietHobby.
It Isn't Easy - POSTED ON: May 20, 2011
I wish there was a magic trick I could tell you, but the bottom line is that the ongoing dieting that is nessary for our weight-loss and for our maintenance of that weight-loss is often hard.
If dieting was easy then no one would be fat.
So keep on working toward your food intake goals. one-day-at-a-time…one-step-at-a-time. We are in a marathon without a finish line, but we have the ability to develop a positive attitude, which will make it possible to continue on.
I posted my last saved recipe video -- which was made before my broken arm. See it here. I don't plan to make any new cooking videos until I can use both hands again. This would be a good time to check out the entire RECIPE section for videos of recipes you might have missed
Also you can find all of my Thinspiration Moment Videos together in the RESOURCES section, under Videos, by clicking the Title "Thinspiration Moments".
If you feel you've missed any Blog articles, or want to review those previously posted, you can quickly access them in the ARCHIVES.
Inconveniences - POSTED ON: May 19, 2011
Life sometimes has problems. How I look at those difficulties, and what I tell myself about them, and how I choose to deal with them, makes a great deal of difference in my mood and in the quality of my life.
For the past four weeks I have been recovering from two broken bones that connect my arm to my wrist. Because I am over 60 years old, recovery might be a bit slow. So patience is necessary.
My arm hurts, and I am unable to tolerate pain medication. There are a great many things that are difficult to do with one hand, and many more things that are impossible. Therefore my normal activities are greatly restricted.
For example, yesterday morning I decided I wanted to cook dinner. I chose my easy recipe for Mild Chili Beans which is posted here at DietHobby under RECIPES, Mealtime.
It takes at least twice as much effort to do everything. I got hamburger meat from the freezer, a can of tomatoes, a can of kidney beans, and seasoning mix from the pantry.
When I got out the raw onion, it then occurred to me that I would be unable to peel, slice, and chop it. Then I realized that I also couldn’t open the cans, or access the pot that I use to cook this recipe.
These inconveniences were relatively minor and merely temporary, but they interfered with my immediate plans, and I’m not fond of that. I felt the emotions that are common to us all in such situations. So what to do?
I could give in to those negative emotions …and wallow in them for awhile…, or I could choose to deliberately focus my mind on the positives of my life that still exist in my current situation in a purposeful attempt to give myself a better day. I have learned from my own experience that this choice is what determines the quality of my life.
I began calling to mind all of the things I have to feel grateful for, and all of the things that I can still immediately do. This did make me feel better, and soon a solution presented itself to me. I decided to ask my husband to cut up the onion, to open the cans, and to get out the pan. He did those things for me when he got home from work, and I was able to cook dinner.
This is a small example of a big principle, and I’ve found that it applies to every situation in my life.
Inspiration - Diet & Book Reviews - POSTED ON: May 18, 2011
A basic idea is to develop sustainable habit that lead to reaching and maintaining a lower weight. One needs the behavior of consistently eating in a manner that results in one’s food intake totaling the same ...for maintenance.. or less…for weight-loss.. caloric energy than one’s body uses. This is simple, but not easy.
There is no one list of “correct” eating habits for everyone. There are some who need to combine exercise with diet, but there is no magic highway to success. We all have to find our own way. We have to find what works for us. And I have learned that…over time…what works individually may change.
As part of my Dieting Hobby, I read many diet books. Here's a link to a video I previously posted about that practice. I also experiment personally with various diets. Here at DietHobby, sometimes I will share information about this in detail, and other times, I will not.
This week I’ve been reading “Weight Loss for Food Lovers” (2008) by George Blair. After I’ve finished reading it, while I’m still processing the ideas presented, I will probably share some of the concepts that I find interesting, but I don’t plan to do a summary or detailed book review.
My overall goal is NOT to provide a comprehensive review of all the various diets, or even of my all own personal ways of eating. My goal is to share the information that I find interesting along with my thoughts, as they occur, which I find helpful to me in my own maintenance.
Everything I do here at DietHobby is to help me maintain my weight-loss. Hopefully some of the things I share will also be helpful to others. I welcome questions, ideas, and opinions from readers. Unless on extremely private issues, I prefer to see them in the Comments section, so that everyone can participate in any discussion, but e-mails are also welcome. My intention is to respond individually to each one. Thanks for being here.
Forgiveness - POSTED ON: May 17, 2011
Forgiving ourselves isn’t about forgetting. It’s about not bringing the offense up to ourselves in negative ways. Forgiving ourselves is simply letting go of what we are holding against ourselves so that we can move on. It’s important to learn from mistakes. What good are mistakes if we don’t learn from them? They are bound to come up again if we don’t correct the problem the first time. There are some things that are hard to grasp the first time around and we may not even realize that it is a problem, but if it comes around over and over again we should recognize that something is probably wrong somewhere. Learning and growing is a never-ending process, so we need to get a clue as soon as possible and save ourselves a lot of aggravation.
Even though we make mistakes, It’s important not be too hard on ourselves. Being human means that we won’t be perfect ….so accept it and move on. This will make us happier and give our self-esteem a positive break.
We need to forgive ourselves. It is okay to ask God and/or others to forgive us, but it is also important that we forgive ourselves. Forgiving ourselves gives us freedom from guilt and pain and it helps us move on with life in a positive way. Each of us can be our own worst enemy so we need to forgive ourselves and choose to be happy with our decisions and the rest of our lives.
Each of us needs to follow our own path. There is a certain path that everyone must take for himself or herself. Following someone else’s path for our lives can lead us down a long road full of sorrows.
I pray for guidance in finding my own path and believe that my Higher Power is directing me. When we find ourselves taking a detour, we need to have the courage to stop, turn around, and get back on our own true path.
Forgiving ourselves doesn’t let us off the hook, it doesn’t justify what we have done, and it isn’t a sign of weakness. Forgiveness is a choice that takes courage and strength, and it gives us the opportunity to become an overcomer rather than remaining a victim of our own scorn.
Mar 01, 2021 DietHobby: A Digital Scrapbook. 2000+ Blogs and 500+ Videos in DietHobby reflect my personal experience in weight-loss and maintenance. One-size-doesn't-fit-all, and I address many ways-of-eating whenever they become interesting or applicable to me.
Jun 01, 2020 DietHobby is my Personal Blog Website. DietHobby sells nothing; posts no advertisements; accepts no contributions. It does not recommend or endorse any specific diets, ways-of-eating, lifestyles, supplements, foods, products, activities, or memberships.
May 01, 2017 DietHobby is Mobile-Friendly. Technical changes! It is now easier to view DietHobby on iPhones and other mobile devices.